Advertisement
Your Extra Help Benefits Are Only as Good as the Plan You Choose
If you qualify for Medicare's Extra Help program — sometimes called the Low Income Subsidy — you already know it can dramatically reduce what you pay for prescription drugs. But here's something many people don't realize: even with Extra Help, choosing the wrong Part D plan can mean paying more than you should. Finding the best Medicare Part D plan for Extra Help recipients isn't just about having the benefit — it's about pairing it with the right plan for your specific medications.
The good news? Extra Help gives you more flexibility than standard Medicare enrollment allows. This article will walk you through how to use that flexibility, what to watch out for, and exactly how to find a plan that stretches your Extra Help dollars as far as possible.
What Extra Help Actually Covers
Extra Help is a federal program that assists Medicare recipients with limited income in paying for Part D prescription drug costs. Depending on your income and resources, it can cover some or all of your Part D premium, eliminate or significantly reduce your deductible, and bring your copays down to as low as $0 to $10 per prescription. Altogether, the program can save eligible enrollees up to $5,300 per year.
There are two levels of Extra Help — full and partial — and the exact savings you receive depend on your income, household size, and the state you live in. Amounts also change from year to year, so it's worth reviewing your coverage annually.
The Special Enrollment Period That Changes Everything
One of the biggest advantages of having Extra Help is a little-known enrollment rule that most Medicare beneficiaries don't have access to: Extra Help recipients can switch Part D plans once per calendar quarter during the first three quarters of the year (January through September), and then again during the annual Open Enrollment Period in the fall.
For most people on Medicare, plan changes are locked in once Open Enrollment ends. But if you have Extra Help, you have multiple opportunities throughout the year to find a better plan if your needs change, your medications change, or you simply realize your current plan isn't working well for you.
This flexibility is powerful — but only if you use it.
Why the Wrong Plan Still Costs You Money
Here's where many Extra Help recipients leave money on the table. Even with the subsidy reducing your costs, not all Part D plans treat every drug the same way. Plans use something called a formulary — a list of covered drugs — and they place medications into different tiers, each with a different copay level.
Under Extra Help, your copay for a given drug depends partly on what tier that drug sits on within your plan's formulary. A medication on a preferred tier may cost you very little or nothing. The same medication on a non-preferred or specialty tier could cost significantly more — sometimes the maximum copay allowed under Extra Help rather than the minimum.
In other words, two Extra Help recipients taking the exact same medications could end up paying very different amounts simply because they're enrolled in different plans. That difference can add up to hundreds of dollars over the course of a year.
How to Find the Best Medicare Part D Plan for Extra Help Recipients
The single most important tool for finding the right plan is the Medicare Plan Finder at medicare.gov. Here's how to use it effectively:
- Enter your specific medications. Don't search in general terms. Enter each drug you take, the dosage, and how often you fill it. The tool will show you exactly what each plan would charge you for those drugs — including your out-of-pocket costs as an Extra Help recipient.
- Filter for Extra Help status. The Plan Finder allows you to indicate that you receive Extra Help. Make sure this is selected so the cost estimates reflect your actual subsidy level.
- Compare total drug costs, not just premiums. A plan with a $0 premium might look great, but if your medications land on higher tiers in that plan's formulary, your annual drug costs could be higher than in a plan with a modest premium. Look at total estimated yearly drug costs.
- Check pharmacy networks. Some plans have preferred pharmacy networks where your Extra Help copays are lower. If you have a preferred pharmacy you use regularly, make sure it's in-network — and ideally a preferred pharmacy — under any plan you're considering.
- Look at mail-order options. Many plans offer lower copays for a 90-day supply through a mail-order pharmacy. For maintenance medications you take every month, this can meaningfully reduce what you pay.
Don't Forget About Benchmark Plans
Each year, Medicare identifies certain Part D plans called benchmark plans in each region. If you have full Extra Help, you can enroll in a benchmark plan with a $0 premium — meaning Extra Help covers the entire premium cost. If your current plan is no longer a benchmark plan (this can change year to year), you may end up paying a portion of the premium out of pocket even with full Extra Help.
Medicare should notify you if your plan loses benchmark status, but it's smart to check for yourself each fall during Open Enrollment to make sure you're not being quietly shifted into a plan that now costs you more.
What to Do If You're Unsure
If comparing plans on your own feels overwhelming, you don't have to do it alone. State Health Insurance Assistance Programs (SHIPs) offer free, unbiased counseling from trained volunteers who can help you review your current plan and compare alternatives based on your specific drug list. There's no cost and no sales pressure.
SHIP counselors can run a personalized plan comparison using your actual medications and help you understand exactly what you'd pay under each option — including your Extra Help copays.
You can find your local SHIP by visiting shiphelp.org or by calling 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227).
Take Action Before Your Costs Add Up
Extra Help is one of the most valuable programs available to Medicare recipients with limited income — but it works best when you're enrolled in a plan built around your needs. Spending an hour reviewing your options can save you hundreds of dollars over the year, and the resources to do it are completely free.
If you haven't already applied for Extra Help, you can check your eligibility and apply online at ssa.gov/extrahelp or by calling Social Security at 1-800-772-1213. If you already receive Extra Help, use your next available enrollment window to make sure you're in the best Medicare Part D plan for Extra Help recipients given your current medications and pharmacy preferences. Your coverage — and your wallet — are worth a second look.
Advertisement
